Why you should avoid these years Toyota Tacoma 2016-2017.
- Alan
- Aug 11
- 3 min read
The Toyota has built a solid reputation among truck lovers for its reliability, strong performance, and rugged off-road capabilities. Yet, if you are considering a Tacoma from 2016 or 2017, it is important to approach with caution. These models have received mixed reviews and highlighted common problems that may make you think again. In this post, we'll examine the reasons potential buyers should be a wear of these specific years, including reported issues, recalls, and performance shortcomings.
Common Issues with the 2016-2017 Toyota Tacoma
One key reason to rethink buying the 2016-2017 Tacoma is the transmission problems many owners have reported. The 2016 model, in particular, has been scrutinized for its automatic transmission, with problems of rough shifting, delayed response, and in severe cases, complete transmission failure. According to user reviews, around 30% of drivers reported issues that required costly repairs, leading to a horrible driving experience.
If you are thinking about buying a used Tacoma from these years, it’s wise to get a complete vehicle inspection to see any potential transmission problems early.
Another frequent problem is excessive road noise in the cabin, especially noticeable at highway speeds. Nearly 40% of Tacoma owners found the noise level distracting, affecting the overall driving experience. If a silent cabin is important to you, the 2016-2017 Tacoma may not fit the bill.
Recalls and Safety Concerns
Safety should always be first when selecting a vehicle, and the 2016-2017 Toyota Tacoma has been involved in many recalls. A notable recall involved problems with the rear leaf springs that could fracture, putting you at risk of losing control while driving. This is particularly concerning for those who use their Tacoma for towing or off-road activities.
but there is more, there were recalls with defects in the airbag system, which could fail to deploy in a crash. Despite Toyota's strong safety reputation, these recalls raise valid concerns about the relatability of the 2016-2017 models.
Fuel Economy and Performance
Though the Tacoma is celebrated for its off-road ability, the fuel efficiency of the 2016-2017 models has drawn criticism from many owners. The 2016 Tacoma was marketed with a combined fuel economy of approximately 21 MPG. However, numerous drivers report achieving only around 16-18 MPG in real-life driving scenarios, a significant drop that might affect your budget if you plan to use it daily.
If fuel economy is high on your priority list, it may be worth looking at rival models in the midsize truck category that offer better efficiency.
Interior Quality and Comfort
The interior quality of the 2016-2017 Tacoma has also faced its share of criticism. While designed for durability, some owners describe the materials as feeling cheap and less premium compared to its competitors, such as the Ford Ranger and Chevy Colorado.
Comfort is another area of concern, with some drivers finding the seats unconfutable on long trips. If you intend to use your Tacoma for daily commuting or extended journeys, it is important to test the interior layout to ensure it meets your comfort standards.
Off-Road Capabilities
While the Toyota Tacoma is well-known for its off-road capabilities, the 2016-2017 models have not consistently lived up to those expectations. Some owners report that these models lack the ground clearance and suspension quality necessary to tackle challenging terrains effectively. In fact, nearly 25% of off-road enthusiasts expressed disappointment with these specific models when compared to earlier versions.
If off-road performance is crucial to you, you might want to explore earlier models or other brands that have a proven history of handling rugged conditions.
Final Thoughts
In summary, the 2016-2017 Toyota Tacoma, despite its legacy, presents a range of concerns for prospective buyers. From ongoing transmission problems and safety recalls to questions about fuel economy and interior comfort, there are several factors to consider before making a buy.
If you're in the market for a midsize truck, exploring different options or looking at older models with proven reliability could save you a fortune. Always conduct diligent research and extensive

inspections to help ensure that you are making a sound investment.
Understanding the potential challenges linked with the 2016-2017 Toyota Tacoma enables you to make a more informed decision and find a vehicle that truly meets your needs.



Comments